I note with interest the presence of a single apparent female in the Group of 21.
Lara Aleluia da Silva Reis interest in seeking "climate justice" as Head of Topic "Sustainable Transitions to Net-zero and Beyond" could raise questions of confirmation bias?
Roger, please comment on your opinion about accuracy of the lower RPC levels and rank the plausible impact on heat, sea level, extreme weather, mental health. It’s one thing to debunk 8.5 and the process used to arrive at these scenarios, but another to state your scientific opinion on these matters, including a timeline for varying forms of possible consequences. Apologies if you have presented this already - if yes, please link.
We will need to await the IAM and GCM runs with the new scenarios before anything meaningful can be said about projections with the new scenarios. But if you want to calibrate plausible projected physical impacts against past scenarios, you can use SSP2-4.5 for medium (and squint a bit as MEDIUM is a tidge higher) and SSP2-6.0 for HIGH (which is two tidges lower).
Thank you Roger for once again showing how exactly the small group of neo-Malthusian elites is in fact controlling the “science”, surrounding climate change. It takes us back to the years when appearing on the Johnny Carson show was an authoritative step for a “scientist” or “researcher” and Paul Erlich logged something like 20 appearances, more than any other “expert”. Boomer aged people may remember him, but they don’t remember a collective reckoning for the fact that he was completely wrong about everything. Not just incorrect, but batshit crazy incorrect. These climate “researchers” are getting away with the exact same behavior as they manufacture fictitious futures for planet earth that serve the purposes of their neo-Malthusian donors. It must stop!
Upon further reflection of this article, I would suggest that this not merely a' 'governance gap' in terms of lacking accountability and transparency, and that problem may be more serious . Given the cozy (incestuous as an earlier writer commented) relationship of the player it seems the real danger what social-psychologist Irving Janis described as 'Groupthink' back in 1972 and how highly intelligent and cohesive groups could still make catastrophic decisions.
See if this applies:
Groupthink is a psychological phenomenon where the desire for harmony or conformity in a group leads to irrational or poor decision-making.
Definition and Mechanism
Groupthink occurs when members of a cohesive group prioritize consensus over critical evaluation, suppressing dissenting opinions and ignoring alternative perspectives. This often results in decisions that are unrealistic, risky, or unethical.
Causes of Groupthink
- Several factors contribute to groupthink:
- High group cohesiveness: Strong desire to maintain unity can override critical thinking.
- Homogeneity: Groups with similar backgrounds or perspectives are less likely to consider alternative viewpoints.
- Directive leadership: Leaders who strongly favor a particular decision can discourage dissent.
- Stress and time pressure: Urgency can push members to conform quickly without thorough evaluation.
- Isolation from outside opinions: Limited input from external sources reduces critical scrutiny.
Symptoms:
Janis identified eight key symptoms of groupthink:
Illusion of invulnerability – excessive optimism and risk-taking.
Collective rationalization – discounting warnings or negative feedback.
Belief in inherent morality – assuming the group’s decisions are morally correct.
Stereotyping outsiders – viewing critics as weak or misguided.
Direct pressure on dissenters – discouraging opposing views.
Self-censorship – withholding personal doubts.
Illusion of unanimity – assuming everyone agrees.
Mindguards – members protecting the group from dissenting information.
Consequences:
Groupthink can lead to poor decision-making, ethical oversights, and catastrophic outcomes. Historical examples include the Challenger disaster, the Bay of Pigs invasion, and failures in foreign policy decisions. Even in smaller organizations, it can result in suboptimal business or team decisions.
Prevention:
To reduce groupthink:
Encourage open debate and dissent.
Include diverse perspectives in decision-making.
Assign a “devil’s advocate” to challenge ideas.
Seek input from external experts.
Break large groups into smaller independent teams for discussion.
Understanding groupthink helps organizations and teams recognize the subtle pressures that can compromise judgment and take steps to foster critical thinking and independent evaluation.
In his 2021 book, Steven Koonin suggest that the IPCC should be "Red Teamed' ( an appropriate colour for a Devil's Advocate) to challenge their ideas. This is long over due
From the article: "The lead modellers [sic] in creating the NGFS scenarios are also lead authors of the CMIP7 scenarios, and are funded by advocacy organizations with a stated interest in specific climate policies, with a rack record in promoting extreme, implausible scenarios. If that sounds odd or troubling — It is!"
I thought the US healthcare industry was bad with regards to conflicts of interest, but climate may actually be worse.
I once analogized the IPCC to a bunch of environmental activists self-appointed and SELF-PERPETUATING to serve as the prosecutors, judge and jury of a court in which they try our fossil fuel-based society and find it guilty without any defense attorneys being present (or law defining our crime).
More seriously, Schneider's infamous remarks about the alleged "ethical double bind" facing climate scientists illustrates the enormous difference between real science and policy making. "As scientists we are ethically bound to the scientific method, in effect promising to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but — which means that we must include all the doubts, the caveats, the ifs, ands, and buts. On the other hand, we are not just scientists but human beings as well. And like most people we'd like to see the world a better place, which in this context translates into our working to reduce the risk of potentially disastrous climatic change. To do that we need to get some broad-based support, to capture the public's imagination. That, of course, entails getting loads of media coverage. So we have to offer up scary scenarios, make simplified, dramatic statements, and make little mention of any doubts we might have. This 'double ethical bind' we frequently find ourselves in cannot be solved by any formula. Each of us has to decide what the right balance is between being effective and being honest."
In the world of politics, and law, no one is expected to tell the whole truth with all of the caveats. Instead, there is a formal adversarial process in which where each side is guaranteed is equal time to present their case and cross-examine their opponents. "Truth" or good policy is expected to be found without trusting anyone to be candid or much less truthful. In the world of science, as Schneider notes, everyone is expected to tell the whole truth with all of the caveats. The world of policymaking from science can have the worst aspects of both politics and science. Distinguished professors may be asked to speak to the public and testify to Congress because of their scientific credibility and then behave like ambulance-chasing attorneys. The IPCC's Summaries for Policymakers contain a great deal of scientific information, but not the "the doubts, the caveats, the ifs, ands, and buts" that characterize ethical science. They offer up scary scenarios like RCP 8.5, make simplified, dramatic statements about catastrophic climate change, and make little mention of any doubts they might have about RCP 8.5 being a "business-as-usual" scenario. If you are an ethical scientist who always tells the whole truth with all of the caveats when communicating with fellow scientists, what makes you think you don't owe the public the same candor?
The loss of scientific credibility was an enormous problem during the pandemic. The initial estimates from epidemiologists that 1-2 million American lives would be lost if the government took no action were spot on. About 300,000 Americans died unnecessarily from vaccine hesitancy. In March of 2020, on the average each infected person was infecting 3.5 new victims leading to a doubling of cases every 2.5 days. Within days of instituting lockdowns, the reproduction rate began falling sharply and reached 1.0 by April 15, but the public felt lockdowns were a failure because the pandemic didn't end. (More effective measures in South Korea and Taiwan reduced their reproduction rate to about 0.5-1.0, allowing the number of cases to remain low and fall between outbreaks.
Schneider's admission (made in 1989) pre-dated much of the climate change controversy. Before then, he worked on the planet-wide "nuclear winter" that would follow a nuclear exchange between the US and the USSR. Eventually, that was downgraded to a "nuclear autumn" as modeling improved. Schneider is considered by some to be the father of the IPCC and the principal advisor for Gore's "An Inconvenient Truth". The passage is so damning that a climate activist working for Wikipedia repeatedly removed it from Schneider's biography. I find it clearly illuminates the difference between the scientific process for learning "the truth" and the adversarial process used by attorneys in courtrooms and politicians. There is a superb book titled "A Constitution of Knowledge. In Defense of Truth" that discusses human cognitive weaknesses (such as confirmation bias and emotion dominating reasoning) and where truth can be found in today's world.
Schneider had a career-long struggle with climate communication and was always an alarmist. Similar concerns can be found in his 1976 book The Genesis Strategy which was required reading in my first introduction to Climatology in 1980. I still have a dog-eared paperback copy. Despite revisionist warmists of today, global cooling was considered the big threat back then.
Roger, your work on how the climate models and scenarios are generated is exemplary!
Even if the scenarios are credible one has to question the predictive accuracy of the models themselves. In 2018 McKitrick and Christy published their work testing the predictive accuracy of the models for the forty-year period between 1978 to 2018, comparing output from 35 models used by IPCC to the actual global average temperature from satellite and atmospheric balloon data and found the global average 2018 temperature predicted by the models was 0.6 deg C higher than that observed. This is a big miss considering that the consensus rise over the past 150 years is about 1.1 deg C. Christy states that the models indicate an energy radiation away from earth equal to 1.4 watts per meter squared compared to 2.6 observed. The authors statement sums it up: “As such, the average of the models is considered to be untruthful in representing the recent decades of climate variation and change, and thus would be inappropriate for use in predicting future changes in the climate or for related policy decisions.”
Sooo.... we an unelected select group of people, that are largely unaccountable and non-transparent deciding the fate of 8 Billion people - not very democratic is it? It also comes across as somewhat neo-colonial.
Thanks Roger, you justify my subscription to THB many times over. It is my impression that President Trump has withdrawn all support for these climate change conclaves and removed the need for the USA to follow their verdicts. This pleased me greatly, but I did not find any reference to such steps in this article. I believe (not sure) Argentina has done the same. In my opinion all countries need to follow this liberating example. No European country has shown a desire to be thus liberated as far as I am aware but I am far from a dedicated observer of these developments.
The only purpose the models serve is to perform hypothesis testing on the climate theory (or whatever you want to call it) that underlies the models themselves. When the models are run and compared against historical data (hindcasting), the divergence in results shows how badly the models perform. Because all (32?) models grossly over-predict temperature, we can be assured that our climate theories are far from complete. Missing from models, as I understand, is cloud droplet formation (interaction of solar and background gamma radiation) and upper tropospheric mixing.
So, models are useful only for demonstrating that we should never use model results for any form of policy-making.
Wow, this is definitely more troubling than at least I thought.
In Norway we live under the impression that we have a division between the Government who excersive our laws, the Parliament who gives our laws and the courts who juge on the rule of law. Surrounding them is the ever vigilant watchdog called the free press, who according to themselves shall be the ever correcting force of society towards the Rulers.
At least that is how it is meant to be.
What is stunning to me is that the story you are telling here is not hidden from view, it is not secret - but it is nonetheless never investigated by that watchdog, the ones who have taken it upon themselves to be ever critical of government and the law, to be our societal quality assurance folks, to be the ones pionting out the glaring inconsistences wherever and whatever they may be.
But the watchdog is cosily snuggled up, feeding on the constant stream of climate sausage that gives this feeling of righteousness, of being vigilantly opposed to everyone not thinking the right thoughts.
I still hope that some journalist somewhere will pick this up and get back on the real mission again.
Same (theoretical) structure in the USA and the free press hasn't been doing their job here for at least the last 30 years. Instead of investigating absurd claims and what motivates them (follow the money) they just reprint press releases from the climate alarmists and every other Malthusian organization.
This is an incredibly disturbing thing to read. As a retired Canadian Geophysicist I have, or had, this rather nieve view that all that's really required in my coumtry is to inform decision makers of the miniscule temperature impacts that IPCC modeling suggests would result from a particular emission reduction strategy. My understanding is that the temperature impact of Canada achieving net-zero by 2050 is 0.02°C by 2100 as opposed to business as usual. I got this number from a Lomborg article and I fully admit that I can’t point to which particular model was used and what the assumptions were for business as usual. What I believe is that this number is at least in the ballpark. Why then would any institution or government body recommend a significant diversion of capital away from any other priority to achieve this? I think Roger has shown why. Institutions are receiving guidelines to follow that have been established by the power structure described in the article. There's little room to make decisions based on a commonsense grounding of temperature impacts unless a particular CEO or politician wishes to challenge something they're not equipped to do.
Your expose' highlights the incestuous relationship between scientists, politically motivated activists, and scientific administrators. Without any internal checks and balances, these organizations have no motivation to change themselves. Your critique will need the support of a powerful outside entity to initiate the needed change.
China and India need not participate or fund these environmental exercises because they can and do ignore their recommendations.
I note with interest the presence of a single apparent female in the Group of 21.
Lara Aleluia da Silva Reis interest in seeking "climate justice" as Head of Topic "Sustainable Transitions to Net-zero and Beyond" could raise questions of confirmation bias?
https://www.eiee.org/topics/sustainable-transitions-to-net-zero-and-beyond/
Roger, please comment on your opinion about accuracy of the lower RPC levels and rank the plausible impact on heat, sea level, extreme weather, mental health. It’s one thing to debunk 8.5 and the process used to arrive at these scenarios, but another to state your scientific opinion on these matters, including a timeline for varying forms of possible consequences. Apologies if you have presented this already - if yes, please link.
We will need to await the IAM and GCM runs with the new scenarios before anything meaningful can be said about projections with the new scenarios. But if you want to calibrate plausible projected physical impacts against past scenarios, you can use SSP2-4.5 for medium (and squint a bit as MEDIUM is a tidge higher) and SSP2-6.0 for HIGH (which is two tidges lower).
Thank you Roger for once again showing how exactly the small group of neo-Malthusian elites is in fact controlling the “science”, surrounding climate change. It takes us back to the years when appearing on the Johnny Carson show was an authoritative step for a “scientist” or “researcher” and Paul Erlich logged something like 20 appearances, more than any other “expert”. Boomer aged people may remember him, but they don’t remember a collective reckoning for the fact that he was completely wrong about everything. Not just incorrect, but batshit crazy incorrect. These climate “researchers” are getting away with the exact same behavior as they manufacture fictitious futures for planet earth that serve the purposes of their neo-Malthusian donors. It must stop!
The term “self-licking ice cream cone” comes to mind…
Upon further reflection of this article, I would suggest that this not merely a' 'governance gap' in terms of lacking accountability and transparency, and that problem may be more serious . Given the cozy (incestuous as an earlier writer commented) relationship of the player it seems the real danger what social-psychologist Irving Janis described as 'Groupthink' back in 1972 and how highly intelligent and cohesive groups could still make catastrophic decisions.
See if this applies:
Groupthink is a psychological phenomenon where the desire for harmony or conformity in a group leads to irrational or poor decision-making.
Definition and Mechanism
Groupthink occurs when members of a cohesive group prioritize consensus over critical evaluation, suppressing dissenting opinions and ignoring alternative perspectives. This often results in decisions that are unrealistic, risky, or unethical.
Causes of Groupthink
- Several factors contribute to groupthink:
- High group cohesiveness: Strong desire to maintain unity can override critical thinking.
- Homogeneity: Groups with similar backgrounds or perspectives are less likely to consider alternative viewpoints.
- Directive leadership: Leaders who strongly favor a particular decision can discourage dissent.
- Stress and time pressure: Urgency can push members to conform quickly without thorough evaluation.
- Isolation from outside opinions: Limited input from external sources reduces critical scrutiny.
Symptoms:
Janis identified eight key symptoms of groupthink:
Illusion of invulnerability – excessive optimism and risk-taking.
Collective rationalization – discounting warnings or negative feedback.
Belief in inherent morality – assuming the group’s decisions are morally correct.
Stereotyping outsiders – viewing critics as weak or misguided.
Direct pressure on dissenters – discouraging opposing views.
Self-censorship – withholding personal doubts.
Illusion of unanimity – assuming everyone agrees.
Mindguards – members protecting the group from dissenting information.
Consequences:
Groupthink can lead to poor decision-making, ethical oversights, and catastrophic outcomes. Historical examples include the Challenger disaster, the Bay of Pigs invasion, and failures in foreign policy decisions. Even in smaller organizations, it can result in suboptimal business or team decisions.
Prevention:
To reduce groupthink:
Encourage open debate and dissent.
Include diverse perspectives in decision-making.
Assign a “devil’s advocate” to challenge ideas.
Seek input from external experts.
Break large groups into smaller independent teams for discussion.
Understanding groupthink helps organizations and teams recognize the subtle pressures that can compromise judgment and take steps to foster critical thinking and independent evaluation.
In his 2021 book, Steven Koonin suggest that the IPCC should be "Red Teamed' ( an appropriate colour for a Devil's Advocate) to challenge their ideas. This is long over due
From the article: "The lead modellers [sic] in creating the NGFS scenarios are also lead authors of the CMIP7 scenarios, and are funded by advocacy organizations with a stated interest in specific climate policies, with a rack record in promoting extreme, implausible scenarios. If that sounds odd or troubling — It is!"
I thought the US healthcare industry was bad with regards to conflicts of interest, but climate may actually be worse.
I once analogized the IPCC to a bunch of environmental activists self-appointed and SELF-PERPETUATING to serve as the prosecutors, judge and jury of a court in which they try our fossil fuel-based society and find it guilty without any defense attorneys being present (or law defining our crime).
More seriously, Schneider's infamous remarks about the alleged "ethical double bind" facing climate scientists illustrates the enormous difference between real science and policy making. "As scientists we are ethically bound to the scientific method, in effect promising to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but — which means that we must include all the doubts, the caveats, the ifs, ands, and buts. On the other hand, we are not just scientists but human beings as well. And like most people we'd like to see the world a better place, which in this context translates into our working to reduce the risk of potentially disastrous climatic change. To do that we need to get some broad-based support, to capture the public's imagination. That, of course, entails getting loads of media coverage. So we have to offer up scary scenarios, make simplified, dramatic statements, and make little mention of any doubts we might have. This 'double ethical bind' we frequently find ourselves in cannot be solved by any formula. Each of us has to decide what the right balance is between being effective and being honest."
In the world of politics, and law, no one is expected to tell the whole truth with all of the caveats. Instead, there is a formal adversarial process in which where each side is guaranteed is equal time to present their case and cross-examine their opponents. "Truth" or good policy is expected to be found without trusting anyone to be candid or much less truthful. In the world of science, as Schneider notes, everyone is expected to tell the whole truth with all of the caveats. The world of policymaking from science can have the worst aspects of both politics and science. Distinguished professors may be asked to speak to the public and testify to Congress because of their scientific credibility and then behave like ambulance-chasing attorneys. The IPCC's Summaries for Policymakers contain a great deal of scientific information, but not the "the doubts, the caveats, the ifs, ands, and buts" that characterize ethical science. They offer up scary scenarios like RCP 8.5, make simplified, dramatic statements about catastrophic climate change, and make little mention of any doubts they might have about RCP 8.5 being a "business-as-usual" scenario. If you are an ethical scientist who always tells the whole truth with all of the caveats when communicating with fellow scientists, what makes you think you don't owe the public the same candor?
The loss of scientific credibility was an enormous problem during the pandemic. The initial estimates from epidemiologists that 1-2 million American lives would be lost if the government took no action were spot on. About 300,000 Americans died unnecessarily from vaccine hesitancy. In March of 2020, on the average each infected person was infecting 3.5 new victims leading to a doubling of cases every 2.5 days. Within days of instituting lockdowns, the reproduction rate began falling sharply and reached 1.0 by April 15, but the public felt lockdowns were a failure because the pandemic didn't end. (More effective measures in South Korea and Taiwan reduced their reproduction rate to about 0.5-1.0, allowing the number of cases to remain low and fall between outbreaks.
Well, at least Schneider was willing to admit what was really going on
Schneider's admission (made in 1989) pre-dated much of the climate change controversy. Before then, he worked on the planet-wide "nuclear winter" that would follow a nuclear exchange between the US and the USSR. Eventually, that was downgraded to a "nuclear autumn" as modeling improved. Schneider is considered by some to be the father of the IPCC and the principal advisor for Gore's "An Inconvenient Truth". The passage is so damning that a climate activist working for Wikipedia repeatedly removed it from Schneider's biography. I find it clearly illuminates the difference between the scientific process for learning "the truth" and the adversarial process used by attorneys in courtrooms and politicians. There is a superb book titled "A Constitution of Knowledge. In Defense of Truth" that discusses human cognitive weaknesses (such as confirmation bias and emotion dominating reasoning) and where truth can be found in today's world.
Schneider had a career-long struggle with climate communication and was always an alarmist. Similar concerns can be found in his 1976 book The Genesis Strategy which was required reading in my first introduction to Climatology in 1980. I still have a dog-eared paperback copy. Despite revisionist warmists of today, global cooling was considered the big threat back then.
Roger, your work on how the climate models and scenarios are generated is exemplary!
Even if the scenarios are credible one has to question the predictive accuracy of the models themselves. In 2018 McKitrick and Christy published their work testing the predictive accuracy of the models for the forty-year period between 1978 to 2018, comparing output from 35 models used by IPCC to the actual global average temperature from satellite and atmospheric balloon data and found the global average 2018 temperature predicted by the models was 0.6 deg C higher than that observed. This is a big miss considering that the consensus rise over the past 150 years is about 1.1 deg C. Christy states that the models indicate an energy radiation away from earth equal to 1.4 watts per meter squared compared to 2.6 observed. The authors statement sums it up: “As such, the average of the models is considered to be untruthful in representing the recent decades of climate variation and change, and thus would be inappropriate for use in predicting future changes in the climate or for related policy decisions.”
Sooo.... we an unelected select group of people, that are largely unaccountable and non-transparent deciding the fate of 8 Billion people - not very democratic is it? It also comes across as somewhat neo-colonial.
Thanks for the insight Roger!
Thanks Roger, you justify my subscription to THB many times over. It is my impression that President Trump has withdrawn all support for these climate change conclaves and removed the need for the USA to follow their verdicts. This pleased me greatly, but I did not find any reference to such steps in this article. I believe (not sure) Argentina has done the same. In my opinion all countries need to follow this liberating example. No European country has shown a desire to be thus liberated as far as I am aware but I am far from a dedicated observer of these developments.
Least useful comment ever. I'm happy you could find the info you were looking for @Roger since one of my companies designed that CMIP website :-)
The only purpose the models serve is to perform hypothesis testing on the climate theory (or whatever you want to call it) that underlies the models themselves. When the models are run and compared against historical data (hindcasting), the divergence in results shows how badly the models perform. Because all (32?) models grossly over-predict temperature, we can be assured that our climate theories are far from complete. Missing from models, as I understand, is cloud droplet formation (interaction of solar and background gamma radiation) and upper tropospheric mixing.
So, models are useful only for demonstrating that we should never use model results for any form of policy-making.
What a total circle jerk by fools with inflated egos !!
Wow, this is definitely more troubling than at least I thought.
In Norway we live under the impression that we have a division between the Government who excersive our laws, the Parliament who gives our laws and the courts who juge on the rule of law. Surrounding them is the ever vigilant watchdog called the free press, who according to themselves shall be the ever correcting force of society towards the Rulers.
At least that is how it is meant to be.
What is stunning to me is that the story you are telling here is not hidden from view, it is not secret - but it is nonetheless never investigated by that watchdog, the ones who have taken it upon themselves to be ever critical of government and the law, to be our societal quality assurance folks, to be the ones pionting out the glaring inconsistences wherever and whatever they may be.
But the watchdog is cosily snuggled up, feeding on the constant stream of climate sausage that gives this feeling of righteousness, of being vigilantly opposed to everyone not thinking the right thoughts.
I still hope that some journalist somewhere will pick this up and get back on the real mission again.
Same (theoretical) structure in the USA and the free press hasn't been doing their job here for at least the last 30 years. Instead of investigating absurd claims and what motivates them (follow the money) they just reprint press releases from the climate alarmists and every other Malthusian organization.
This is an incredibly disturbing thing to read. As a retired Canadian Geophysicist I have, or had, this rather nieve view that all that's really required in my coumtry is to inform decision makers of the miniscule temperature impacts that IPCC modeling suggests would result from a particular emission reduction strategy. My understanding is that the temperature impact of Canada achieving net-zero by 2050 is 0.02°C by 2100 as opposed to business as usual. I got this number from a Lomborg article and I fully admit that I can’t point to which particular model was used and what the assumptions were for business as usual. What I believe is that this number is at least in the ballpark. Why then would any institution or government body recommend a significant diversion of capital away from any other priority to achieve this? I think Roger has shown why. Institutions are receiving guidelines to follow that have been established by the power structure described in the article. There's little room to make decisions based on a commonsense grounding of temperature impacts unless a particular CEO or politician wishes to challenge something they're not equipped to do.
Your expose' highlights the incestuous relationship between scientists, politically motivated activists, and scientific administrators. Without any internal checks and balances, these organizations have no motivation to change themselves. Your critique will need the support of a powerful outside entity to initiate the needed change.
China and India need not participate or fund these environmental exercises because they can and do ignore their recommendations.
"incestuous" - catchy