Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ken Bowdon's avatar

On David Blackmon’s Substack the other day he brings out that the Hunga Tonga-Hunga Ha’apai undersea volcano last year blew 146 trillion grams of water into the upper atmosphere. NASA JPL was estimating that it may cause warming of as much as 1.5 C for 2 to 3 years any many parts of the globe. And cooling in others. That is one volcano, albeit a large one.

Within the ring of fire it is estimated that there are millions of hydrothermal vents in subduction zones around the planet. James E. Kamis has developed a theory called Plate climatology. Heat flux from the mantle has been completely ignored in climate science but it can explain many climate phenomenon. He just published a book last year. “Geological Impacts on Climate”. As a practicing geologist for the past 45 years it really rang a bell for me. It is a fascinating read. The theory is that heat flux from the mantle through subduction trenches and mid sea rises contributes greatly to warming the oceans from below.

Subduction trenches such as the Marianas Trench are the thinnest crust on the planet. With trillions of gallons of water subducted into hot rock. El Niño, if you will notice starts at a single source point every time. It is cyclical but not consistent, much like other volcanic features such as geysers and subsea hydrothermal vents. Temperature profiles of El Niño show warmer waters below. Climatologists struggle with how heat is stored in deep ocean water. It is not from the atmosphere, heat comes from below.

El Niño in his theory is the direct result of volcanic and hydrothermal activity above the Marianas subduction zone east of Papua Nw Guinea.

Techtonic features below Western Antarctic shelf with dozens of active under ice volcanoes has a heat flux 10 times the heat flux in Eastern Antarctica, explaining why all the ice loss in Antarctica is from the Western Shelf while Eastern Antarctica remains stable.

Water in the Bering sea are warmed by volcanic activity in the Alaskan peninsula, another subduction zone and under sea volcanoes off the coast of northwestern Canada. Currents from the Bering sea move to the Arctic through the Bering straight contributing to melting sea ice distribution in the Arctic.

Same in Greenland. Heat flux from crust at one time overlaying a mantle plume, now under Iceland still has a heat flux 5 times higher than southern Greenland. There, as in the Antarctic, the ice is melting from below. Nowhere does any of this show up in climate models.

There is little to no research being done on this theory. The theory seems sound but more research needs to be done. He derived the theory from basic geological and geophysical studies. Just as it took Plate Tectonics 70 years to become mainstream, hope it doesn’t take that long for this theory to be tested.

Expand full comment
Rod Dobson's avatar

I very much enjoy your work. A question though -- can you help me understand how events like the current Canadian wildfires fit into the equation? They are obviously a serious challenge, and equally obviously helped along by the weather trends this year. We should be looking at mitigation strategies, of course, but there is no direct economic impact reported that I am aware of, other than on some smaller communities that experience loss, and the health impacts that follow on from the smoke generated which will be hard to isolate and quantify. In Canada, these are Crown lands, and I doubt that there is any insurance claim for the loss of a valuable asset. Is this a type of under-reporting that we should be aware of?

Expand full comment
19 more comments...

No posts